Magnum47's art Reviews on Newgrounds

[Russian Gas Mask (GP-5)]

Looks pretty good, but compared to my actual GP-5 there are some mistakes.

#1 Gp-5s are grey, this is black and thus a GP-5M.
#2 Eyeholes a bit too high up.
#3 Filter a bit too long.
#4 Lenses a bit too close to the surface.
#5 the folds near the filter are all wrong
#6 No stampings on either the mask or filter.
#7 GP-5s are rubber, so why the yellow stitching?
#8 lense holders a bit too thin
#9 Filter still has the plug in it.
#10 Clasps on filter holder and lense holders slightly off, and a lack of grey cloth under them.
#11 no visible stiffeners in the lenses, i know they are reflective but no matter how much those things are always visible on the outside, as they are right up against the lenses.
#12 No visible stiffener marks on the outside leading to the filter from the lenses either.
#13 eyeholes a bit too far apart.

But still, this is alot better than I'll ever be able to do, so props on that.
Like, not bashing you or anything, but those are just the flaws that jumped out at me compared to my own mask.

Cheers m8,
~Mag47

Carr77 responds:

Haha, thanks for your comment. I don't have a mask of my own, so some details were hard to find references for, so it's fun to see whether I managed to guess right or wrong concerning some of these details. The color of the mask (black) and the yellow stitching were creative decisions I made to make it look more cool, but besides from that I tried to be pretty accurate, so it's fun to read your comment and see how well I did / didn't do.

Perhaps you already saw it in the description, but in case you missed it, you can check out the mask in 3D in your browser at Artstation, in case you want to rotate the model around and check the details ;)

https://www.artstation.com/artwork/mgKRe

Bye & thanks for your comment!

[Photostudy7]

Only question, why did you censor Krönen?

[Nazi Luger]

Nice! Good art, good proportions, and overall good gun to choose. But there are a few historical inaccuracies. #1 While the Nazi Party did issue Lugers to some officers early in the war, they did not issue red grips with a swastika on it. and the barrel should be shorter. and lasty, the way you have the swatika facing (points facing left instead of right) means it is the swastika of peace. odd because it is on a nazi gun.

[Evolutions of Cethic]

i honestly kinda hate 4.

[Deimos]

am i the only one who thought Deimos' headset cord was a mullet?

[Commission: einhajar12]

@alshikh because SANFORD is the arsonist of the two.

[chicken wing]

is that Mathew santoro in the sky?

[Frozen City]

it ok if i use this in a pivot anim? i will link it 2 u wen dun

[Hank from madness combat]

could you release a download so i can use this in alice? it says alice can use 3d max files